Saturday, March 29, 2025

Utilities are out of control! Urge your legislators to oppose bad utility and water bills.

This was the last week to hear bills in committee at the Arizona Legislature, except for hearing bills in the Appropriations Committee. So there are no new Request to Speak actions. But we are recommending four other actions to take: sending messages to your Legislators against two harmful utility bills, a bad energy bill, and a water bill that codifies over pumping of groundwater. (See actions and links below.) 

Now for a little good news. It appears that HB2552 to codify hounding of wildlife is really dead, a bill to exempt fracking for helium without an aquifer protection permit -- SB1444 -- is dead, and the original version of the bill to hinder siting of wind farms -- HB2223 -- is also dead (note there is a strike-everything amendment to revive it). SB1068, a bill to limit protecting additional federal public lands never made it out of the senate.


HB2201 and HB2679 have gone through committees and are now going for a floor vote. Please use the Sierra Club forms to contact your Senator. 


While HB2201, a bill that would relieve the electric utilities of responsibility for harm from wildfires caused by their infrastructure and make them less accountable, was amended, it still relieves utilities of negligence related to wildfires caused by their infrastructure. Please continue to keep up the pressure on this bill as it should not advance as is.

Take action on HB2201

Please take action to tell your senator to oppose HB2679, a bill that allows utilities to use a type of bonding for an extremely broad range of things and without accountability or consumer protection.

NOTE: Please, correct the two typos in the subject line. The action is only for HB2679 and it is incorrectly written as HB2201 and HB2649. In the first paragraph of the message, it also incorrectly calls it HB2649. Please, change it to HB2679. 

Take action on HB2679

HB2774 NOW: small modular reactors; co-location (Carbone) has passed out of the Arizona House and is ready to go to the floor in the Senate. It preempts counties – except Maricopa and Pima – from regulating the location of these small modular nuclear reactors if they are co-located with a large industrial electricity user – basically data centers. We already have data centers located here pretty indiscriminately and using enormous amounts of water and electricity – providing very few jobs. Why give them even less accountability, especially in rural areas where our water resources are even more constrained?

HB2774 also says small modular reactors are not subject to requirements for a certificate of environmental compatibility (CEC), if they are being co-located with a big electricity user, aka data centers. Again, the impacts of data centers on the water and the grid are enormous and a CEC should be required. It also allows a small modular reactor to replace a gas plant or other thermal plant that received a CEC without getting a new CEC. This is also a bad idea as the impacts and concerns about nuclear are different from those about fossil generation.

Ask your Senator to please vote No on HB2774!

Help Limit Groundwater Pumping!

SB1520 Now: Rural Water (Dunn) establishes an extremely weak system for groundwater "management" in a limited number of areas in rural Arizona. The bill caps the percentage reduction in groundwater pumping at one percent annually and not more than 10 percent over 10 years, far below what is needed to stabilize these and other aquifers in our state. This bill also includes weak goals that do not promote stabilizing the aquifers to limit land subsidence, earth fissures, and the continued decline of water levels, which are drying up wells in some areas. 

Tell Your Representatives to oppose SB1520 . Let legislators know that we care about water throughout Arizona.

Sunday, March 23, 2025

Celebrate World Water Day: Advocate for Water & Public Lands

Next week there are a bunch of bad water, utility and energy, and democracy bills on the agendas.  There are 16 Request to Speak actions in all. Keep an eye out for the one bill we are supporting: HB2518. Please, weigh in on the bills on the RTS system before they are heard in their respective committees.  (See list below.) 

Sign into the Request to Speak system here: https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon

Next week, there will be a rally at the Capitol for Public Lands. Please join the Sierra Club Thursday, March 27th at 1:00 PM. For details and to RSVP, go here:

https://act.sierraclub.org/events/details?id=701Po00000l56MsIAI&formcampaignid=701Po00000j4yzmIAA




Saturday, March 15, 2025

Request to Speak on the Bad Bills that Encourage Over-pumping and Discourage Clean Energy

Groundwater over-pumping brought to you by the AZ Legislature

This week at the Arizona Legislature, several bad water bills are being heard in committee as well as some bad energy and governance bills. Please weigh in on them on the Request to Speak app anytime before they are heard in committee. (Example: weigh in on HB2274 before it is heard Tuesday at 1:30pm.) 

Back again this week is HB2223 wind farms; construction; policies; procedures (Marshall: Blackman, Diaz, et al), which includes numerous new mandates for wind energy generation facilities that are clearly intended to stop wind projects from being sited. Please take action and send a message to your representatives asking them to oppose this anti-clean energy bill.

https://act.sierraclub.org/actions/arizona?actionid=ar0529742&id=70131000001iOuIAAU

Sign into the Request to Speak system here: https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon

Tuesday, March 18th

Senate Natural Resource Committee at 1:30 PM
Members of the public may attend in person or access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • HB2274 NOW: water improvement district; Willcox basin (Griffin) authorizes Cochise County to call a special election for a water improvement district for water hauling and to develop a standpipe (a really big water tank).  Right now, the county is working on the new active management area and programs associated with it. This could potentially conflict with the AMA. While we appreciate that this bill includes water harvesting to improve infiltration, this bill doesn't do enough to address the underlying issue of overpumping of groundwater. OPPOSE
  • HB2573 Now: groundwater; plants; wine grapes; nonirrigation (Griffin) provides a massive exemption for wine grapes – water for these is not considered irrigation and therefore is not subject to limits on pumping in an AMA. This is yet another big loophole proposed for the Groundwater Management Act and would be harmful and undercut groundwater programs in the new Willcox AMA. OPPOSE 
  • HB2788 utility; resource plan; commission review (Olson) states that "if feasible" utilities can do a greenhouse gas emissions analysis, but it doesn't allow those greenhouse emissions to be used in the decision making process for keeping power plants in service or building new plants. It tips the scales in favor of fossil fuels. OPPOSE 
  • HCM2014 corporation commission; reliable energy (Olson), with the amendment, asks the Arizona Corporation Commission to prevent regulated utilities from going "Net Zero" and shutting down dispatchable sources of energy generation and replacing them with “costly, intermittent and unreliable solar, wind and battery storage." First of all, this statement is false, they are not costly or unreliable, but they are intermittent. Solar, paired with battery storage is dispatchable, helping to address intermittency issues. Coal is more expensive to run than replacement with new solar. The memorial includes a lot of misinformation about renewables, including that the renewable energy standard has cost Arizona ratepayers. To the contrary, a 2020 report by Ceres found “more than $1.5 billion and $469 million in gross benefits for the public and customers of Arizona Public Service (APS) and Tucson Electric Power (TEP), respectively.” It also found savings of about 7,129-acre feet of water annually, and a 3% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. OPPOSE 
House Natural Resources, Energy, & Water Committee at 2:00 PM
House Regulatory Oversight Committee at 3:00 PM
  • SB1432 prohibition; geoengineering (Farnsworth) deals with the wacky conspiracy theory on chemtrails. I am not sure what else to say about it, but I would suggest opposing it. OPPOSE
Wednesday, March 19th

House Ways and Means Committee at 9:00 AM
  • SCR1009 revenue increases; administrative fee authorization (Mesnard) refers a proposed constitutional amendment to the ballot that would eliminate the legislature’s ability to authorize an agency to establish fees without a two-thirds vote. This would make it even more difficult to implement important programs to protect our health and environment. OPPOSE
Senate Judiciary and Elections Committee at 1:30 PM
  • HCR2057 initiatives; referendums; signature requirement; counties (Keshel) refers a proposed constitutional amendment to the ballot that requires a proportionate number of signatures from each county for statewide initiatives, constitutional amendments, and referenda. This just makes it harder for citizens to make their voices heard. OPPOSE
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
  • SB1534 ballot measures; description; legislative council  (Kavanagh) shifts the responsibility for drafting the short description and ballot language for a ballot measure from the secretary of state and attorney general to the legislative council, which would further politicize it. OPPOSE
House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee at 2:00 PM

Friday, March 14, 2025

Call your Senators: The Continuing Resolution that advances DOGE goes to a vote today

Senators Mark Kelly and Ruben Gallego

Call your Senators now: The Continuing Resolution goes to a vote in the Senate today.

While our Senators Mark Kelly and Ruben Gallego say that they oppose the Continuing Resolution, if they vote for cloture, the Republicans will be able to pass the CR with a simple majority (instead of the usual 60 votes.) It is a performative act to vote "yes" on cloture and "no" on the CR - which will still allow it to pass. They need to stand strong for their constituents and the U.S.

1 Review Script

“I’m calling as a constituent in Tucson (include zip code) to urge you to oppose the Continuing Resolution because it would enable DOGE to further dismantle the government. You also need to vote against cloture which would allow a simple majority to pass the bill. "

2 Make the Call
Sen. Mark Kelly (202) 224-2235
Tucson office: (520) 475-5177

https://www.kelly.senate.gov/contact/contact-form/

Sen. Ruben Gallego (202) 224-4521
Tucson office:
520-777-0400

https://www.gallego.senate.gov/share-your-opinion/

Saturday, March 8, 2025

This Week's Action: Protecting Our National and State Parks

Protect the Grand Canyon from uranium mining! 

The good news is that we don't have a lot of Request to Speak bills to weigh in on this week. The bad news is that's because we already weighed in on them and they advanced to the other chamber. Please weigh in on these two bills before they are heard in committee Tuesday at 1:30pm. 

Since we have such an easy week, please take a couple of minutes to fill out the petitions below.  The first one is to oppose the defunding of the Inflation Reduction Act and the other one urges Secretary Burgum to protect the Grand Canyon from mining. Finally, I'm sure we all are concerned about the firings at our beloved national parks. You might consider heading to the state capitol to protest. (See details below.) 

Sign into the Request to Speak here: https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon
Tuesday, March 11th

Senate Natural Resource Committee at 1:30 PM 
Members of the public may attend in person or access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • HB2577 native plants; fire prevention; exemption (Griffin: Lopez) exempts the Department of Forestry and Fire Management from the Native Plant Law notification requirements relative to fire management, protection, and suppression. In general, allowing firefighters the ability to fight fires without worrying about violating state law regarding native plants would make sense - except this goes too far by allowing the state forester to remove any amount of native plants in the service of fire prevention. That could include our beloved saguaros. OPPOSE
  • HCM2003 stormwater; groundwater; recharge; urging support (Griffin) asks that the Arizona Department of Water Resources and State Land Department develop specific recharge projects on state trust lands that were identified as suitable groundwater recharge sites. SUPPORT 
Sign to Keep the Inflation Reduction Act intact

Clean energy delivers massive benefits, from good-paying jobs to lower pollution risks, to lower energy prices, and the American people overwhelmingly support clean energy. Clean energy investments are delivering for communities across the country and defunding clean energy will just increase pollution and put people out of work. The cost of obstructing clean energy progress is too high: From slower job growth and lost economic benefits to volatile energy prices and increasingly damaging and expensive extreme weather disasters.

Tell your member of Congress to be strong in protecting climate investments!

Make your voice heard: sign this petition to tell Congress to keep the Inflation Reduction Act intact and to oppose efforts to repeal climate protections!

https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/save-clean-energy-2/?source=AZSierraClub

Protect the Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon National Monument

In January, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum issued an order for a review of national monuments and mineral withdrawals — part of the Trump administration's plan for “unleashing American energy." In response, a coalition of Tribes, conservation organizations and community groups came to the defense of Baaj Nwaavjo I’tah Kukveni – Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon National Monument, the newest national monument in Arizona.

The monument safeguards nearly one million acres surrounding the iconic Grand Canyon National Park from new uranium mining claims. Those protections could be at risk under the Trump administration's review.

Designated by President Joe Biden in 2023, it was originally proposed by the Grand Canyon Tribal Coalition, including 14 Tribal Nations, and preceded by a 2012 mineral withdrawal safeguarding the region and Grand Canyon’s aquifers and springs from new uranium mining.

Please take a moment to sign a petition to Secretary Burgum. The Sierra Club will share it with him and with our U.S. senators, both of whom have spoken out to defend this national monument.

https://act.sierraclub.org/actions/Arizona?actionId=AR0521102


Join our Arizona Public Lands and Waters Rally alongside a diverse coalition of organizations fighting to protect our beloved parks, forests, and monuments—and to support the workers who help them thrive. We’ll gather at the Arizona Capitol to hear from inspiring speakers who share a deep connection to the lands that make Arizona special. Let’s show up, speak out, and take a stand for our public lands! 

1pm to 3pm, March 27th at the Arizona State Capitol  

 For more information and to RSVP, go here: 

https://act.sierraclub.org/events/details?id=701Po00000jAyXIIA0&formcampaignid=701Po00000j4yzmIAA

Saturday, March 1, 2025

Utilities, Water and Mountain Lions. Oh, my!

Let's start with a little good news at the AZ Legislature. The House did defeat HB2588 wildlife; taking; landowner permits; rules . The bill ordered the Game and Fish Department to issue landowner permits for killing wildlife such as elk, deer, and antelope (it included oryx, which we do not even have in Arizona), and would have allowed these landowner tags to be expanded. HB2588 was a step toward privatizing wildlife and contrary to the public trust. Wildlife in the United States, unlike in many other countries, belongs to the people, not the government and not to individuals. All 27 Democrats were joined by 13 Republicans in defeating the bill.

But our quest to protect wildlife continues. Please, use the Sierra Club petition to urge your representatives to oppose HB2552 dogs; hunting; rules; prohibition that makes hound hunting allowable in statute, eliminating the discretion of the Arizona Game and Fish Commission to limit hunting with hounds during certain seasons or under certain conditions. HB2552 would sidetrack efforts to limit hound hunting of animals such as mountain lions.

 

Unfortunately, the big electric utilities were at the legislature in force with a gaggle of lobbyists pushing for their terrible legislation. What we did not anticipate is that more Democrats would give Arizona Public Service (APS), Salt River Project (SRP), and Tucson Electric Power (TEP) a way to avoid responsibility for their action or inaction relative to wildfires. Unfortunately, the following Democrats joined with Republicans to pass HB2201:  Abeytia, Aguilar, Blattman, Connolly, L. Contreras, A. Hernandez, C. Hernandez,  L. Hernandez, Luna-Najera, Simacek, Travers, and Tsosie. The bill would not have passed without their support and is now in the Senate. If these are your representatives, please let them know you are disappointed with their vote on HB2201 and then urge them to vote "No" on the next big utility bill, HB2679.   You can find their emails and phone numbers here


There are just a handful of new bills to weigh in on in the Request to Speak app. Please, weigh in on them before they are heard in committee. (The committee times are listed below.) 

Sign into the Request to Speak here: https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon

Tuesday, March 4th


Senate Natural Resource Committee at 1:30 PM
  • HCR2016 reinstatement; WIFA monies (Griffin) This resolution commits to full funding of the Water Infrastructure Finance Authority (WIFA) dollars - especially the long-term water augmentation fund that seeks water importation projects. It would be better to focus funds on conservation and reuse rather than seeking sources from other states or countries that might not be as reliable. OPPOSE
Wednesday, March 4th

House Government Committee at 9:00 AM
Senate Judiciary and Elections Committee at 1:30 PM
  • HB2017 voting centers ban; precinct size (Keshel) prohibits the Board of Supervisors from authorizing the use of voting centers, removes language allowing a County Recorder to establish on-site early voting locations, and limits the size of election precincts to a maximum of 1,000 registered voters. All of these will hinder, not help, people voting early. OPPOSE
  • HCR2002 voting centers; precinct voting (Keshel) is the same as HB2017 above, except that it would go to the ballot. OPPOSE
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
  • SB1142 elections; foreign contributions; prohibition (Finchem: Angius, Carroll, et al.) prohibits foreign funding for influencing elections, but also requires that everyone who files a report certify that they have not accepted any goods or in-kind contributions from a foreign entity. SUPPORT

Saturday, February 22, 2025

Urge your Legislators to vote "No" on bad water and utility bills

Water level declines graphic with pump