Saturday, February 8, 2025

Request to Speak on bills that hurt wildlife, water and voting

HB2224 makes this unlawful

This week was utility and dirty energy week at the Arizona Legislature as committees advanced bills to allow utilities to get out of liability for negligence relating to wildfires and to broadly apply a financial mechanism to reduce costs of debt on power plants without retiring them. They also passed a bill to require that utilities have a right of first refusal for construction of renewables and to block wind energy.

Please contact your representatives using the Sierra Club form on this link to oppose HB2201 and HB2679bills that would relieve electric utilities of responsibility for wildfires caused by their infrastructure and would allow them to issue bonds to pay for debt in assets without proper accountability, oversight, or consumer protection, and could shift major costs to future ratepayers.

You may be wondering why we do Request to Speak actions when some of the bills still get passed. Our RTS positions support the governor when she vetoes bad bills.

Coming up this week are some pretty awful wildlife bills and more bills to weaken our already weak water laws. I am especially concerned about  HB2224 unlawful wildlife feeding; enforcement; penalty that makes it unlawful to knowingly create wildlife habitat. This would totally negate creating urban wildlife habitat for any animals except birds.

Don't forget to support or oppose bills in the Request to Speak system. There are actually two bills we SUPPORT this week!  Note that you do not have to speak if you use the system, you can just sign in with a position on the bills.

Please weigh in on the following bills on the Request to Speak app anytime while they are still in committee.

https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon

If you haven't signed up for the system, you can find the form here:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScdjBMoAJrjHD57GGegmdUCKAowcr93K4vQA6a7_AjyElBtrQ/viewform

Directions on how to navigate the system:

https://desktopactivisttucson.blogspot.com/2018/03/request-to-speak-time.html

Monday, February 10th

House Land, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs at 2:00 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • HB2083 game and fish commission; membership (Griffin: Diaz, Hendrix, et al) requires that one member of the Game and Fish Commission be a "cattleman or rancher." Many in the livestock industry have a huge conflict when it comes to wildlife as they advocate for killing off predators and anything that might compete with cattle for forage. OPPOSE
  • HB2224 unlawful wildlife feeding; enforcement; penalty (Gress: Bliss, Carter P, et al.) makes it unlawful to knowingly create wildlife habitat and establishes a $1000 fine in a city or town of 100,000 people or more. This would totally negate creating urban wildlife habitat for any animals except birds. OPPOSE
  • HB2552 dogs; hunting; rules; prohibition (Diaz: Carter P, Griffin, et al) prohibits the Game and Fish Commission from limiting hunting with hounds. This would sidetrack efforts to limit hound hunting of animals such as mountain lions. OPPOSE
Tuesday, February 11th

Senate Natural Resources Committee at 2:00 PM 
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • SB1309 public utilities; electric grid improvements (Carroll: Angius) Includes a requirement of a "generation resource mix." That means you must use more than one type of energy source - which could include coal and gas power.  OPPOSE 
  • SB1501 grid security; cybersecurity; reviews; commission (Farnsworth) requires the Arizona Corporation Commission to conduct an annual grid security review of a power plant and to consider research and evaluate grid management technologies, protect against physical and cyber attacks, and to assess emerging technologies, including distributed energy resources, microgrids, and new technology battery storage.  SUPPORT
  • SB1521 unbuilt certificates; assured water supply (Dunn) It would allow a developer with a certificate of assured water supply to sell the certificate for use in another location within a municipal water service area - even if they are not in the same basin and regardless of where the municipal water service is coming from. OPPOSE
  • SB1523 water use; prohibition; landscaping (Dunn) Overall this is a good bill. It doesn't allow cities to require turf (except for recreational use) or plants that aren't included on the low-water, drought tolerant plant list. But the bad part is that  you can't require a minimum number of trees (like the Mayor's Million Trees Initiative), open space, or detached sidewalks. OPPOSE
House Natural Resources, Energy, and Water Committee at 2:00 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • HB2087 appropriation; groundwater recharge facilities; maintenance (Griffin: Diaz, Gowan, et al) appropriates an unspecified amount for cleaning and restoring underground storage facilities for flood control in a subsequent AMA. It is unclear what that would mean. The bill doesn't designate what department will be responsible for doing this and doesn't define what the artificial groundwater recharge facility is. Essentially it doesn't fill in the details. OPPOSE  
  • HB2127 hazardous substance release; notice; liability (Bliss) includes notification and disclosure requirements for property that has been contaminated by hazardous substances when it is sold. SUPPORT
  • HB2270 groundwater model; stormwater recharge; AMAs (Griffin) requires the AZ Department of Water Resources to offset a portion of future groundwater use as a result of infrastructure development when they update the groundwater models. It is the model that should determine groundwater availability, not the legislature. OPPOSE
  • HB2272 municipal separate storm sewer system (Griffin) This weakens the protections for surface water in the state from small municipal storm sewer systems. OPPOSE
  • HB2574 small land subdivision; requirements (Griffin: Lopez) allows counties to approve small land divisions of 6-10 lots with lots of 2 acres or more, thus getting around subdivision requirements and assured water supply requirements. This creates yet another loophole. OPPOSE
  • HCR2046 Colorado River; cause of decline (Griffin: Diaz, Lopez) says forest mismanagement and salt cedars are the principal cause of Colorado River depletion despite no evidence to support that. Climate change and the associated drought and over-allocation of the river are the principal causes of depletion. OPPOSE
House Regulatory Oversight Committee at 2:00 PM
Wednesday, February 12th
 
House Government Committee at 9:00 AM 
House Ways and Means Committee at 10:00 AM
  • HCR2035 tax prohibition; vehicle mileage; monitoring (Weninger) refers a proposed constitutional amendment to the ballot that prohibits the state and local government from taking actions to reduce vehicle miles traveled. It also prohibits any kind of fee based on vehicle miles traveled. OPPOSE
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
  • HB2038 technical correction; accountants; investigations (Kolodin) will have a strike-everything amendment on S/E: voter registration; citizenship proof requires proof of citizenship for anyone who registered after 2005 if there is some reason to believe they did not provide it.  Why is it only valid through the next election?  OPPOSE
  • HB2060  state sovereign authority; elections (Fink: Keshel, Powell, et al.) Declares the legally dubious sovereign authority doctrine to preempt federal law regarding federal elections. OPPOSE
  • HCM2004 military bases; exemption from ESA (Griffin) asks Congress to exempt military bases from complying with the Endangered Species Act. The military is perfectly capable of complying with the law without compromising its mission. Besides, shouldn't the government be leading by example? OPPOSE
Senate Judiciary and Elections Committee at 1:30 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • SB1463 initiatives; existing laws; impact statement (Mesnard) requires citizen initiatives to include a statement about laws with which it might conflict and that may be impacted. This will become another way to find a technicality and kick a measure off the ballot. OPPOSE 

Sunday, February 2, 2025

Push back on more bad bills at the AZ Legislature this week.

After all the negative bills last week, I thought you could use some good news.

Rep. Nancy Gutierrez's bill, HB 2213, which would fund free school lunches for children whose families meet the federal income requirements for free or reduced-price lunches, passed in the AZ House Education Committee by 9-3! If you are in district 18 and want to thank her for the hard work, her number is (602) 926-4134.

Next action... Contact the chair of the House Appropriations Committee, Rep. David Livingston (R-28) at 602-926-4178 (dlivingston@azleg.gov) and ask him to put the bill on his agenda.

Now back to our Request to Speak actions. There's less than last week, so that's good. And even one bill that supports EVs. Please weigh in on the following bills on the Request to Speak app anytime while they are still in committee.


If you haven't signed up for the system, you can find the form here:


Directions on how to navigate the system:


Monday, February 3rd


House Land, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs at 2:00 PM 
  • HB2201 technical correction; electricity; power authority (Griffin) will have a strike-everything amendment on S/E: wildfire mitigation planning; utilities; approval. The strike-everything basically gives the utilities near immunity for negligence related to wildfires. The wildfire mitigation plan is automatically approved once submitted. The ACC can request changes, but the power authority doesn't have to make them. This bill makes it nearly impossible to hold the power authority responsible for the damages they cause. OPPOSE
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee
  • HB2703 early voting; tabulation; ballot deadlines (Hendrix: Chaplik, Heap, et al) moves up the deadline for early ballots to 7pm the Friday before the election, and requires those with early ballots on Election Day to show ID and go through the lines. It eliminates emergency voting too. OPPOSE
Tuesday, February 4th

Senate Natural Resources Committee at 2:00 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • Presentation
    • The State of Agriculture in Arizona, Patrick Bray, Executive Vice President, Arizona Farm and Ranch Group
  • SB1113 renewable energy; public service corporations (Dunn) requires utilities to have the right of first refusal to construct, own, or maintain any renewable energy resource in Arizona thus giving utilities a potential monopoly on renewables. Why only renewables? Why not gas plants? This is a terrible bill that could block a lot of renewables. OPPOSE
  • SB1114 assured water supply; analysis; availability (Dunn) is an emergency measure that requires the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) to issue a Certificate of Assured Water Supply based on outdated certificates and allows other developers to claim the estimated water savings, up to 15 percent. This creates another way around the assured water supply requirements. OPPOSE 
  • SB1260 assured water supply; agricultural water (Dunn) allows the Director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) to designate a portion of the city or town that is located on lands served by a contracted agricultural water company as having an assured water supply. OPPOSE
House Natural Resources, Energy, and Water Committee at 2:00 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • Presentations:
    • Jim Robb, President & CEO, North American Electric Reliability Company (NERC)
    • Melanie Frye, President & CEO, Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC)
  • HB2223 wind farms; construction; policies; procedures (Marshall: Blackman, Diaz, et al) includes numerous mandates for wind energy generation facilities, including that counties require them to have a bond to indemnify the county from anything related to the wind farm. This is not required of other power generation facilities and is totally unnecessary. OPPOSE
  • HB2527 corporation commission; electricity; reliability; management (Olson) prohibits the Arizona Corporation Commission from authorizing a power plant retirement unless there is a new plant with equal or greater power. It requires that all replacement resources for power plant retirements be thermal (gas, coal, or nuclear) and precludes them from being renewable resources. The effect would likely be to keep coal plants running longer costing ratepayers more dollars -- solar is cheaper than coal. Due to its rate impacts and the restrictions on the ACC, it is also likely unconstitutional. OPPOSE
  • HCR2044 minerals; metals; supporting domestic supply(Griffin: Bliss, Carter P, et al) is another promotion for mining, including uranium mining, and asks for streamlining in permitting. Streamlining involves cutting out the public processes and further ignoring environmental and cultural concerns. OPPOSE
House Regulatory Oversight Committee at 2:00 PM
Wednesday, February 5th
 
Senate Regulatory Affairs and Government Efficiency Committee at 9:00 AM 
  • SB1229 planning; home design; restrictions; prohibition (Bolick: Bravo, Diaz, et al) Takes away power from municipalities to enforce their zoning requirements. Which means that owners can build anything on their lots as long as it complies with building codes (which are more lenient.)  OPPOSE 
  • SB1352 rezoning; administrative act; referral prohibited (Gowan) says a rezoning is an administrative act rather than legislative act and therefore is not referable by citizen petition to the ballot. This would limit communities' ability to stop a rezoning and put it before the voters.  Basically, this messy bill will prevent public opposition to rezoning applications. OPPOSE
  • SB1353 municipal development; permits; review (Gowan).allows permitting to be outsourced if a city does not approve, amend, etc. a permit in 15 days. This would just push cities to churn out permits and privatize local government further. OPPOSE
Senate Government Committee at 9:00 AM
  • SB1256 diversity; equity; inclusion; training; prohibition (Hoffman) prohibits the state from using diversity, equity, and inclusion programs for hiring, training, and promotions. The bill sponsor could benefit from training in this area. OPPOSE
  • SB1313 municipalities; counties; recycling; prohibition (Hoffman: Chaplik, Keshel, et al) says cities and counties should not ask people to place anything in a recycling bin that is not being "actively recycled" at the time of the bill's passage. This would prevent future expansion of recycling programs. OPPOSE
  • SCR1008 municipalities; counties; vote; fee increases (Petersen) refers a measure to the ballot to require that cities and counties have a two-thirds vote to increase any fees, taxes, etc. This will tie the hands of local government just as it has the legislature, except that the legislature has developed several work-around processes. This is government overreach. The state shouldn't mandate that municipalities have a 2/3 vote to increase fees. OPPOSE
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee at 2:00 PM 
Senate Judiciary and Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
  • SB1152 early voting; mailing date (Gowan) reduces early voting from 27 days prior to the election to 21 days before an election. This limits the amount of time for early voting and could affect voter turnout and burden election workers further. OPPOSE
  • SB1280 cast vote record; public record (Finchem: Rogers) requires a county recorder to make available the name, voter ID, and party of every person who voted only one hour after an election. This is an impossible and unnecessary measure. OPPOSE

Sunday, January 26, 2025

Push back on bad bills for our environment, water & voting rights

Sunday, January 19, 2025

Legislative Report & Request to Speak Actions on bad voting bills

(Condensed version of the Sierra Club's Legislative Update)

This week, the 57th Legislature, First Regular Session, kicked off with the Governor's State of the State address -- well and a short prebuttal by Senate President Warren Petersen, who basically said whatever the Governor is for, he is against. Governor Hobbs focused on education, reproductive rights, housing, and water. On water, she talked about the need for limits in rural Arizona and also for developers to be accountable. You can listen to her full speech here or read it here.

Already legislators have introduced hundreds of bills, many of them concerning, including more harmful water legislation, measures to hinder voting, especially early voting, and bills to weaken environmental protection. We have started the bill tracker, but have not filled it out completely yet. You can see the tracker here.

Not unexpectedly, the Senate Judiciary and Elections Committee passed SB1011 early voting; ballot deadlines; certificates (Petersen: Angius, Bolick, et al.) along party lines. It removes authorization for counties to establish emergency voting centers, changes the deadline for dropping off early ballots to the Friday before the election, requires ID for early voting rather than merely allowing people to drop off their early ballot in the signed envelope as we do now. This would result in longer lines and more confusion and generally make early voting more difficult.

The Governor's budget was released today and included several line items related to water, air, waste, and parks. She is asking for $3 million to fund litigation on the Colorado River allocations as Arizona continues to fight with other states over an over allocated river that is stretched beyond its limits. She asks for additional funding for the Arizona Department of Water Resources to fund six additional full-time employees. There is funding for working on state implementation plans to meet Clean Air Act requirements and some funding related to the Iron King Mine, a federal Superfund Site. Of note, this year, the Governor included some funding for the State Parks Heritage Fund -- $2.5 million. While that is far from the $10 million it should be getting, it is better than the big zero it got last year. This is just her proposal and the Legislature is unlikely to embrace it.


REQUEST TO SPEAK ACTIONS 

Don't forget to start registering support or opposition to bills with the Request to Speak system. Note that you do not have to speak if you use the system, you can just sign on the RTS app with a position on bills. If you have not created an account on the Request to Speak System, I encourage you to do so.

Sign onto Request to Speak Here: 

https://apps.azleg.gov/account/signon

If you haven't signed up for the system, you can find the form here: 

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScdjBMoAJrjHD57GGegmdUCKAowcr93K4vQA6a7_AjyElBtrQ/viewform

You can weigh in on bills while they are still in committee. For directions on how to navigate the system, try:

https://desktopactivisttucson.blogspot.com/2018/03/request-to-speak-time.html

Tuesday, January 21st

House Natural Resources, Energy, and Water Committee at 2:00 PM 
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.

Presentations:
  • Overview of the Water Infrastructure Finance Authority (WIFA)
  • Overview of Active Management Areas (AMAs) & Irrigation Non-Expansion Areas (INAs)
  • Overview of the Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ)
  • HCM2003 stormwater; groundwater; recharge; urging support (Griffin) asks that the Arizona Department of Water Resources and State Land Department develop specific recharge projects on state trust lands. 331 sites have been identified by ADWR as having high potential for groundwater recharge. SUPPORT  *
  • HCR2016 reinstatement; WIFA monies (Griffin) is a resolution asking for reinstatement of the Water Infrastructure Finance Authority (WIFA) dollars. As most of these dollars are focused on funding out-of-state augmentation projects, we cannot support this. OPPOSE
Wednesday, January 22nd
 
Senate Government Committee at 9:00 AM 
House Federalism, Military Affairs, & Elections Committee at 2:00 PM
Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here.
  • HB2006 election mailings; third-party disclosures (Gillette) requires organizations that distribute official election-related documents, or documents that resemble official election-related documents, to include the words Not from a Government Agency in boldfaced on the outside of the envelope. This is an attempt to make outreach more difficult for those encouraging voting. OPPOSE
  • HB2017 voting centers ban; precinct size (Keshel) prohibits the Board of Supervisors from authorizing the use of voting centers, removes language allowing a County Recorder to establish on-site early voting locations and limits the size of election precincts to a maximum of 1,000 registered voters. All of these will hinder not help people voting early. OPPOSE
  • HCR2002 voting centers; precinct voting (Keshel) is the same as the measure above, except that it would go to the ballot. OPPOSE
Thursday, January 23rd

Extreme Heat in Arizona and Heat Relief Funding at Noon!

Join the Sierra Club for a compelling and timely webinar presented by Rev. Katie Sexton, Executive Director of Arizona Faith Network, addressing the urgent issue of extreme heat in Arizona and its wide-ranging impacts on vulnerable communities, public health, and regional economies. Arizona faces record-breaking heat year after year, with Phoenix and Tucson ranking among the fastest-warming cities in the nation. Extreme heat amplifies ongoing challenges such as water scarcity, air pollution, environmental racism, and rising healthcare costs, further deepening inequities across our state. Tragically, we have seen hundreds of people die each year throughout the state due to this climate emergency, underscoring the urgent need for immediate action. In this session, Rev. Sexton will explore the need for legislative advocacy for heat relief funding, along with rapid response efforts and ongoing support to help mitigate the climate emergency and protect Arizona's most vulnerable populations.

*This is Sustainable Tucson's take on this particular bill 

Wednesday, January 15, 2025

Weigh in on Plan Tucson by January 31, 2025


Here is your opportunity to have a say on the future of Tucson by weighing in on Plan Tucson.

City boards and commissions apply to the plan when implementing Mayor & Council guidance and making recommendations. City staff refer to the plan for direction on their roles. And citizens can also refer to it when making recommendations. 

The preliminary draft of the Plan Tucson 2025 General Plan Update
 was released last month and the city is looking for feedback. The deadline is January 31st at 5 p.m. 

https://www.plantucson.org/plan-tucson-2025-preliminary-draft-surveys

Explore the preliminary draft at your own pace and provide feedback through the online Plan Tucson 2025 Preliminary Draft Surveys. Surveys for individuals cover:

  • Overview and Implementation [Chapters 1, 2, and 5]These chapters cover the plan overview, history of Tucson, characterization of Tucson today, and plan implementation. 
  • Values, Goals, and Policies [Chapter 3]This chapter covers the draft plan's fourteen goals and associated policies. Provide feedback on as many goals as you like.  
  • Future Growth Scenario Map [Chapter 4]This Chapter focuses on the draft map depicting future growth patterns and development guidelines for the City.
While the Plan Tucson document is admittedly very long, you can scroll down to the sections that are important to you. I recommend checking out Chapter 3, Values Goals and Policies.


Your input is vital to shaping Tucson's future. Visit the Plan Tucson website to review materials and participate in the planning process.

For questions, contact plantucson@tucsonaz.gov.

Saturday, January 4, 2025

Time for Action! Speak to Your Legislators at Environmental Day at the Capitol

Join us for the annual lobby day, Environmental Day at the Capitol, to advocate for environmental issues in our state. This is an opportunity to meet with your legislators, hear from great speakers, and connect with others who are doing advocacy work both inside and outside the Arizona Legislature. No experience necessary. The Sierra Club will be providing online trainings and workshops leading up to this day. They also provide one-sheets on bills they support that protect the environment. Join a small group of fellow citizens from your district to speak to your legislators or just enjoy the presentations! 

Time to Act! Extreme Heat & Climate Justice
Environmental Day at the Arizona Capitol
February 12th, 2025
Arizona Capitol - Wesley Bolin Plaza
1700 W. Washington St.
Phoenix, AZ 85007

Please mark your calendar and RSVP. It is important to register so we know what legislative district you are in and also can plan for food and materials. Also, sign up for the free bus that is provided from Tucson.