before Voting on Proposition 421.
In less than two weeks, Tucsonans will be going to the polls (if they haven't already voted by mail, as I did). The ballot for this election has an overwhelming number of propositions put forward by the state legislature to try to get bills passed that they couldn't get through in the regular session, but there are also a number of local propositions worth considering. Proposition 421, extending Tucson Electric Power's Franchise Agreement, is one of the most contentious.
A lot of Tucsonans I've heard from are viewing Prop 421 as a referendum on TEP. Sure, you can do that, but the reality is that voting No on Prop 421 isn't going to move Tucson toward renewable energy or municipalization any faster. Most of the obstacles to municipal power are legal and financial.
The legal hurdles are state law and Arizona Corporation Commission rules that prevent a lot of the actions environmentalists would like to see: solar shaded transit corridors, Community Choice, and competition within service areas. Voting down Prop 421 won't change any of that.
Financially, the process of condemning TEP infrastructure, purchasing or constructing infrastructure, hiring and training personnel, setting up service centers, and transitioning to a municipal electric utility for the first time in Tucson's history will take a long time and be very expensive. It's also a transition that is likely to be contested in court over a period of many years. In the end, most of the municipalization plans for Tucson are for city owned and operated power transmission and distribution, not generation. So, a new municipal power utility would be buying power in the current energy market. Building new fossil fuel-free generation infrastructure will also be quite expensive and will take years (though solar and storage can be built out relatively quickly). Can a city that has lost revenue from federal and state sources and has a shrinking local tax base afford that investment? It's a question that requires some serious study, not sloganeering.
In the meantime, many of the actions we as a city can take now to make our energy generation mix cleaner require working with TEP. Distributed Capacity Procurement is a promising path forward, but it would need to be done with TEP. I hope we will finally get some renewable energy friendly legislators and regulators to stop putting their thumbs on the scales in favor of fossil fuels, but even this election cycle won't get us all the way there.
Will voting No on Prop 421 get us closer to municipalization? I don't think so. TEP will still be our energy provider. The ACC will still set rates and rules. The only thing that would really change would be that routine maintenance and service expansions will have to go through the City permitting process, costing TEP more and the City more for staff to process the additional permit applications.
Whatever you decide, be sure to vote!
Hi Dan- while I agree with much of your comment above, please produce some evidence on the permitting issue where you repeat what TEP has claimed without any evidence. It recently became clear from comments of several TEP folks that TEP, even with the franchise agreement now in place, DOES GET PERMITS FOR EACH OF THEIR PERMITTABLE PROJECTS, but they have an arrangement where they can get the permits AFTER THE FACT, reversing the usual order. But since City staff must still issue these permits, there seems to be no staff time or money savings from this process.
ReplyDeleteHi Bruce, You are correct that TEP needs a permit for the following work:
ReplyDelete"The Company shall, when required by applicable City Charter, Code, regulation or ordinance, obtain a permit and pay all applicable fees prior to removing, relocating, or reconstructing, if necessary, any portion of its Facilities in the Right-of-way."
My understanding (and I'm not a lawyer, I rely on the City Attorney's office for legal advice) is that normal maintenance does not fall into that "remove, relocate, or reconstruct" category requiring permitting. After-the-fact permitting happens for emergency repairs and that would be true even if Prop 421 is voted down. So, the permitting is significantly streamlined for all utilities that have a Franchise Agreement with the City and would not be streamlined without it, requiring more effort from the Permit Office.
Let's be honest, if there was no difference in the requirements with or without a FA, why would any utility pay to sign one with the City?
Dan Stormont, you’re assigned oversight of the Energy Collaboration Agreement (ECA) funds through your role on the Commission on Climate, Energy and Sustainability, while publicly advocating for Prop 421 and the TEP franchise agreement. That raises a legitimate question about where your responsibility lies: with protecting the public interest or preserving the institutional arrangement over which you exercise oversight.
ReplyDeleteTucsonans deserve transparency about how the franchise agreement affects public accountability, who controls ECA funds, and what safeguards ensure those decisions serve the community—not the people administering them.
Public oversight is a responsibility, not a personal power base.
Dear Anonymous,
DeleteExactly where in this blog post did I tell anyone how to vote on Prop 421? I just made it clear what the proposition will and won't do.
I didn't say that I was a member of the CCES because I was not posting on behalf of the Commission. This post was my personal opinion as a citizen of Tucson. The Commission is a volunteer advisory commission. We have no legal authority to make any decisions - we can only make recommendations to the Mayor & Council that are discussed and agreed upon in public meetings that anyone, including yourself, can attend. Only the Mayor and Council can make decisions about how any funds related to Tucson Resilient Together are spent.
This is not a power trip for any of us. If you have taken the time to look at what we've been working on, you would know we have spent years looking into public power options. We have a tasking from Mayor and Council to provide them a brief on public power options. I am not trying to shill for TEP or build an empire. In fact, that's the last thing I have the time or inclination to do.
I find it very sad that you attribute the worst motives to other people. Like all the members of the Commission, we volunteer because we want to help make Tucson a better, more resilient place to live because we love the place we live.
Dan Stormont, the work you and other commissioners have done is appreciated. Nonetheless, my concern is not whether commissioners are volunteers or whether Mayor and Council retain final decision-making authority. It is about transparency, conflicts of interest, and the influence exercised through overlapping leadership roles.
ReplyDeleteCCES commissioners who also held leadership roles in Citizens’ Climate Lobby advocated to Mayor and Council for the Energy Collaboration Agreement (ECA). The Commission was subsequently tasked with making recommendations concerning ECA-related funding, including consideration of proposals that commissioners themselves helped develop.
Even when final approval rests with Mayor and Council, the ability to shape policy, develop proposals, and recommend public expenditures carries considerable influence.
I have observed how overlapping roles in nonprofit advocacy and municipal advisory bodies can facilitate personal relationships and institutional influence. These relationships warrant scrutiny, particularly when the same individuals participate in advocacy, proposal development, and subsequent recommendations concerning public funding.
This is not about dismissing volunteer service or attributing malicious motives. It is about ensuring that public service remains accountable to the public. Good intentions do not eliminate the need for independent oversight, disclosure of potential conflicts, and transparent decision-making.
With climate change accelerating so quickly, we need to do everything we can to make Tucson more resilient. For example, the mission of Sustainable Tucson is to build an equitable and resilient community that will thrive long into the future in harmony with our natural desert environment. Our purpose is to build regional resilience and sustainability through community engagement, awareness raising, and advocacy. That includes advocating with the City. One of the purposes of Sustainable Tucson's ambassadors program is to educate more people to do that. Many leaders in the sustainability community have spent years (decades even) studying climate solutions and they have dedicated their lives to that endeavor. Doesn't it make sense to have experts on these commissions?
DeleteAll discussions and recommendations made by the CCES (or other advisory commissions in the City of Tucson) are held in public meetings and must comply with State of Arizona Open Meeting Laws. We aren't making any decisions behind closed doors and we welcome public input through the Call to the Audience at every monthly meeting and by inviting speakers to present their positions to the Commission. As an example, when we were preparing a recommendation on Project Blue, we invited environmental groups, data center developers, and utilities to present their viewpoints so we could make an informed decision.
ReplyDeleteOur charter, as defined in City of Tucson Code Section 10A-212 is the following.
The CCES shall advise the mayor and council on:
(a) The most effective and efficient methods of meeting the climate/energy/sustainability goals outlined in the city's general plan.
(b) Methods for improving the city's climate and environmental impact and adaptability in its operations; and
(c) Achieving the incremental as well as transformative systemic outcomes necessary to respond to climate, energy, and broader sustainability challenges in our region.
Given that charter, it is perhaps not surprising that people who are active in the climate, energy, and sustainability communities have been appointed to roles as commissioners by the Mayor, City Manager, or Council Members. Does that mean we only promote the positions of organizations we may also be volunteers with? I often disagree with the positions taken by some of the sustainability groups I volunteer with. I do not personally benefit from any of the positions I take, other than as a Tucsonan trying to make Tucson more livable and resilient.
Finally, the CCES didn't write the ECA. In my blog, I also am not trying to tell anyone to vote for the Franchise Agreement/Energy Collaboration Agreement. All I was pointing out is that the popular sloganeering to "Vote NO on TEP. Vote NO on 421." will not actually mean TEP will not be able to operate in Tucson and will not mean that we will automatically transition to municipal power. That is a very expensive, very lengthy process with a lot of legal hurdles that would have to be overcome. If (and it is probably a big if) Prop 421 passes today, the CCES will do our best to ensure the funds made available for community benefit are being put to the best benefit for the long-term sustainability of the community. That is our role and we will continue to have those conversations in public meetings, inviting feedback from any members of the community who want to offer it.